Sub, in spite of its name, is not for the subtle player. It is fast, it is flashy, and it is very, very timing dependent. When you play sub, either you become one, or you blast Black Powder to the top of the meters. With some of the best burst windows in the game under your belt, if you fancy the gameplay of an ambush predator, coming in, blasting fast and slinking back into the shadows, then Subtlety Rogue might just be the spec for you. Read on for all the info you'll need to decide whether you'd like to sink some time into learning Subtlety for Midnight Season 2. With Xal'atath still floating around, there's no time like the present to dip into the shadows, and see if sitting on timers is the kind of gameplay you might find fun.

By the way, we're running a 15% promotional discount offer on all of our services! All you need to do is pop the code BLOG15 into your checkout page to apply the discount to all items in your cart, be they for WoW, OSRS, League of Legends, or any other game on our website.

What Is Subtlety Rogue?

To start off, we first need to establish what exactly a Sub Rogue is. Two words: BURST DAMAGE. Subtlety Rogue is a dagger shanking, leathear wearing, shadow damage dealing burst whale of a spec that almost entirely relies on short, explosive burst windows to deal the overwhelming majority of its damage. This is the single most important thing to understand when deciding whether you want to try out Sub. If you are good at restraining yourself and properly popping CDs during timing windows that allow you to maximize your damage, then your Sub will hit like a truck, but if you mistime or run out of Shadow Dance, your single most important ability, during an important timing, you will hit like a wet noodle, get out-DPSed by your tank, called slurs by your healer, deplete your key, lose your mortgage, and so on.

The core gameplay loop of Subtlety is keeping an eye on your resources, lining up cooldowns, and knowing how and when to pop your Shadow Dance both in and between burst windows. You also need to be fast with your fingers since this spec is heavily reliant on doing a lot within a very tight time window. In PvE, that can make or break your DPS for each pack or encounter, and in PvP, it can be the difference between blowing up the squishy enemy caster, or getting rooted and forced to watch as a 3 man felts yours.

To play Sub effectively, you need to learn to work within both your own timing windows, and those of your compatriots. If you see your priest has PI, that the boss is about to enter a burn phase, or if the enemy Hunter just fumbled his turtle, you need to be able to react accordingly right that moment so you can pump as much damage into the target as possible. Big deeps done fast. This is the way.

Strengths and Weaknesses

What Subtlety does well:

  • Huge burst damage on a roughly 90 second timer, with smaller windows every time Shadow Dance comes back
  • Short cooldowns and strong single-target damage
  • A relatively simple rotation once you understand how to line your cooldowns up
  • All the usual Rogue mobility and utility, from Shroud of Concealment to Atrophic Poison

Where it struggles:

  • Damage outside of your cooldown windows is peanuts
  • Cleave on two or three targets is underwhelming compared to the other Rogue specs
  • Very tuning-sensitive, the nerf stick hits Subtlety far harder than its sister specs

Tuning might seem like something that you realistically shouldn't worry about, but given Subtlety's make-or-break reliance on precise timings, even small tweaks can completely throw your entire routine out of wack. Sustained 2 or 3 target cleave is also weak compared to Outlaw and Assassination. Let us reiterate: Subtlety only works well if you can dump a ton of damage into your target within a small timing window.

What Changed in Midnight

Midnight reworked Subtlety pretty heavily, so returning players may want to reorient themselves before Shadow Dancing.

Removed:

  • Symbols of Death
  • Flagellation
  • Rupture

Added or reworked:

  •  Ancient Arts, your new Apex Talent, which turns Shadow Techniques into Shadow Clones
  •  Shadow Dance now runs on a static 20 second cooldown, and Deepening Shadows extends its duration based on your Haste instead of reducing its cooldown
  •  Shadow Blades now doubles your combo point generation rather than instantly filling your combo points
  •  Secret Technique runs on a static 25 second cooldown that is reduced by Haste
  •  Supercharger replaces Echoing Reprimand, supercharging a combo point every time you enter Shadow Dance
  •  Cold Blooded Killer is now passive, and Danse Macabre deals Shadow damage

As of Patch 12.1, Goremaw's Bite is a mandatory pick. It hits three targets and gives you a big bleed, but its main use case is still smacking your primary target with a big burst of damage, and only slightly makes your three target cleave better.

Talents, Gear and Stat Priorities

Hero Talents: Deathstalker or Trickster

TLDR: play Deathstalker for PvE and maybe Trickster if you play PvP.

Deathstalker It plays around a stacking debuff called Deathstalker's Mark, which is applied every time you hit your target with Shadowstrike. Every finisher consumes one stack for extra shadow damage. Clearing out all stacks on a target, or if a target dies with stacks still on it, procs Darkest Night, which makes your next 5+ combo point Eviscerate crit, deal 35% additional damage, and apply 3 stacks of Deathstalker's Mark onto the target if it currently has none. This is really, really powerful if timed correctly when you need to swap from one target to the next, especially in Mythic+ packs where you can easily kill a weaker target to get more priority damage on another.

While Trickster was meta in PvE during the last patch, it has more or less completely been supplanted by Deathstalker. Trickster works by giving you better consistent damage by having your Shadowstrike and Backstab have a chance to cast twice, and by applying Fazed to the target. Fazed makes targets take 5% extra damage from you. Once you Faze enough enemies, or one enemy enough times, your Eviscerate becomes Coup de Grace, which casts it with an extra 5 combo points on top of your max.

PvP is a differnet story. In 3v3s, 35 of the top 50 Sub Rogues run Trickster. Solo Shuffle is a bit of a mixed bag with 28 of them running Deathstalker and 22 Trickster. The use case for Trickster over Deathstalker is how well it plays with Smoke Bomb, allowing you to farm Fazed stacks a lot easier. The cutoff is more or less the same, where Trickster gives you more utility and consistency, while Deathstalker gives you even more burst at the expense of Mark management and leaving more room for counterplay. In 3v3s, where you can rely on your teammates more, Trickster shines for its consistency, but in Solo Shuffle where you are effectively only able to rely on your own skill, Deathstalker gives you more room to carry. Of course, if you fancy yourself the carry in 3v3s, run Deathstalker and try to blow up the squishiest enemy. Entire careers have been built on coin flips in Arenas, might as well try your luck.

In clonclusion: Deathstalker beats Trickster in every kind of PvE encounter by a wide margin. The only excuse for playing Trickster is that it does not alter the base Subtlety gameplay loop, unlike Deathstalker, which has you manually handle Mark allocation.

Talent Builds

Subtlety has very few permutations in its talent configs across Mythic+, Raiding and PvP. To start from the back end this time, your PvP talents are very similar to your Raid ones insofar as they hammer home the soul of Subtlety: damge, damage, damage. You want to get Deathstalker, Shadow Blades, Shadowcraft and Goremaw's Bite from your spec tree, and Cold Blooded Killer, Supercharger and Deeper Stratagem from your class tree. Assuming you have your tier-set, Lingering Shadow. If you do not have your four-piece, take Dark Shadow instead. If you're taking them into the Arena or Solo Shuffle, then you want to pick up Smoke Bomb, with either Preemptive Maneuver or Dismantle beside Thick as Thieves as your third pick.

Raid swaps are mostly fight dependent. Potent Powder is a good choice on fights with adds and cleave, Planned Execution over Warning Signs is good for fights with big burn phases, and Gloomblade can be a good choice to pad the space between your Shadow Dances if you're building for 100% pure single target.

Mythic+ is just swapping into Potent Powder and hammering Black Powder as much as possible in every pack with 2+ enemies. That is it. You become the powder man. Everything you do is in service to spamming Black Powder as much as humanly possible in every single pack, then smashing a Darkest Night Eviscerate into your prio target's skull. You can optionally take Shiv instead of Iron Stomach if your group has no dispells, but that's mostly down to personal preference. You can run Delves with either build.

The Rotation

These are the three golden edicts of Subtlety Rogue gameplay:

  • Everything revolves around Shadow Dance; only enter Shadow Dance when Secret Technique is ready, and try to fit two Shadow Dances into every Shadow Blades
  • Never press Shadow Dance during a global cooldown; macro it with something to not waste keystrokes
  • Finish at six or more combo points; Deeper Stratagem and Secret Stratagem push your cap up, and spending early is wasted damage

Single-Target Priority

Running Deathstalker, the priority is as follows:

  • Open with Shadowstrike from Stealth
  • Pop Shadow Dance, farm up six+ combo points and cast Darkest Night + Eviscerate if up, otherwise Secret Technique, otherwise Eviscerate, and build with Shadowstrike
  • Outside Shadow Dance, cast Eviscerate at six or more combo points and build with Backstab
  • Cast Shadow Dance at zero or one combo points when Darkest Night is up or Secret Technique is ready
  • Cast Shadow Blades when Shadow Dance is ready
  • Cast Goremaw's Bite on cooldown, just before Shadow Dance
  • Cast Vanish on cooldown at low combo points

If you're playing Trickster, Secret Technique becomes your top finisher inside Shadow Dance, and you want to enter Shadow Dance at six or more combo points instead.

Cleave & AoE

From two targets upwards, Shuriken Storm replaces Shadow Dance or Backstab and Black Powder replaces Eviscerate. Inside Shadow Dance, your finisher order becomes Secret Technique first, then an empowered Eviscerate from Darkest Night, then Black Powder. At four or more targets, always make sure Secret Technique gets the benefit of Supercharger and Ancient Arts as one of your first two finishers in the window. On exactly two targets, Eviscerate is still as good as or better than Black Powder unless you've taken Potent Powder. Otherwise, spam Black Powder whenever you get to 5+ combo points.

Shadow Dance & Secret Techniques

Shadow Dance is your bread, the capstone, the cheese, the single most important ability you have as a Subtlety Rogue. It gives you all the benefits of being Stealthed, including much faster energy regen, every 20 seconds and enables you to cast Shadowstrike, which is your primary single target combo point builder. Shadow Dance can no longer be cancelled, and Deepening Shadows extends its duration based on your Haste, but not on percentage Haste effects like Bloodlust. Moreover, Supercharger empowers a combo point every time you enter it, so your first big finisher inside the window should always be the highest value one off CD.

Secret Techniques is the butter to your bread. It is a two-part ability that smacks your main target for physical damage, and then echoes that hit twice, with those follow up hits cleaving to up to 5 targets. This makes it not only your best offensive (sans empowered Eviscerate), but also your highest raw damage AoE finisher.

Ancient Arts & Shadow Techniques

And here is your salt and pepper. Shadow Techniques is a passive that gives your auto attacks a chance to restore energy and "store" combo points, which your builder abilities like Backstab or Shadowstrike can then use to generate more actual combo points. The third upgrade of Ancient Arts, your Apex Talent, makes it so that if you cast an finisher with five of more Shadow Techniques stacks in the bank, your next damaging finisher spends them and instantly refills your combo points, meaning you can throw out two fully charged finishers off back to back.

Thus, the optimal play is to hold off on casting your finishers a couple of seconds before ST comes off cooldown, then try to make sure that Ancient Arts lands on the second, supercharged finisher. For single target, that should be Darkest Night Eviscerate, and for AoE, it'll be Secret Technique.

Stat Priority

Agility >> Mastery > Haste (to around 700 rating) > Critical Strike = Versatility

Agility is raw damage in its purest form, which means that except for a few special situations like filling out your tier set, item level increases are generally worth taking even when the secondary stats aren't optimal. Getting Haste to 700 gives you enough wiggle room to stuff more casts into your windows but any more is a bad diminishing return, so consider 700 your personal soft cap. After that, stack as much Mastery as you can, and keep Crit and Verse as dump stats.

In PvP, its the flip side: Verse is your definitive best stat, followed by Mastery, then Crit and Haste a long ways behind.

As always, remember to SIM YOUR CHARACTER! There is a very, very small chance you actually have full BiS gear, so your damage output is going to vary wildly depending on what specific pieces you've got equipped. This list is a general guideline, simming is still the best way to figure out what you want to keep or vendor.

What Patch 12.1.5 Changes

As of the last patch, every Shadow hit, including Secret Technique's clone hits, Shadowed Finishers and Shadow Clone attacks, now benefits from your Shadow damage modifiers properly. Echo effects like Shadow Blades, the Goremaw's Bite mirror and Lingering Shadow now scale correctly off Physical attacks too, without double-dipping on attacks that were already Shadow. Not necessarily a balancing patch, more like Blizzard fixing its own jank. Word of warning, if you're going to roll Sub, be prepared for a lot of jank, as for some reason Blizzard has pegged Subtlety as its testing monkey and loves to smack it with weird changes like this seemingly at random. Sometimes it makes you broken, sometimes it kneecaps you, its coin flips all the way down.

Blizzard hasn't put numbers on the overall impact yet, and says it is still under review, so expect some tuning to follow. Shadow Blades also gets new visuals.

WoW Midnight Subtlety Rogue BiS List: Season 2

This is the current list for Season 2. Every slot assumes a fully farmed season.

SlotItemSource
Main HandZatha'tek, Breath of CorruptionUla'tek
Off HandFarstrider's MercyCrafted
HeadChosen Bloodslayer's Spirit ShroudTier Set
NeckAqirbane ReliquaryUla'tek
ShouldersChosen Bloodslayer's Voodoo GuardsTier Set
CloakSilken Voodoo DrapeThe Coiled Altar
ChestChosen Bloodslayer's Banded PonchoTier Set
WristSilvermoon Agent's DeflectorsCrafted
GlovesChosen Bloodslayer's Fanged GripsTier Set
BeltSash of the Forlorn VesselThe Coiled Altar
LegsChosen Bloodslayer's Reinforced PantsTier Set
BootsGoldfeather BootsKings' Rest
RingsLightwarden's BindThe Blinding Vale
RingsJade Ophidian BandTemple of Ssethralis
TrinketVoracious Heart of Ula'tekUla'tek
TrinketZul'jin's Guillotine TechniqueThe Coiled Altar

As always, your main hand weapon is your single most important bit of gear. Getting a good main hand dagger is priority #1 in ALL cases. After that comes your Tier Set, then Trinkets, then special effect items like the Aqirbane Reliquary. Everything else is after that. Rings and necks are usually just stat bricks, so try to hit whatever you need most with them. If you haven't crafted your weapon, you can fill out whatever other slot you might be lacking in with it.

Your tier set, Chosen Bloodslayer's Hexweave, is your second highest source of raw damage. The two-piece makes Backstab and Shuriken Storm cheaper and much stronger, and the four-piece lets Lingering Shadow empower Eviscerate and Black Powder at 60% effectiveness, down from 100% after the 18 August tuning pass. Remember that the four-piece does nothing without the Lingering Shadow talent. Catalysed pieces keep their stats and effects this season, so you can catalyse whatever gear you have freely.

If you're spending Nebulous Voidcores, Ula'tek is the boss to farm, for the dagger first, then Voracious Heart, then Gaze of the Coiled Watcher and Aqirbane Reliquary. After that, Zul'jin's Guillotine Technique from The Coiled Altar is the next best roll.

As far as PvP Gear is concerned, you get all of it from Honor / Conq through ye olde PvP Vendor. Not much more to say beyond that.

12.1.5 also brings a few gearing changes. From the week of the 20th of October, Ascendant Venomstones let you raise the item level of your weapons, trinkets and necklace past the usual cap, and the crest cap is lifted. Spend them on your mainhand dagger first, then Voracious Heart of Ula'tek, then Zul'jin's Guillotine Technique, then Aqirbane Reliquary. The new single-boss raid, The Unbinding of Kith'ix, and the Labyrinth of Kindo'jan both add new places to gear up alts and such.

Trinkets

Voracious Heart of Ula'tek and Zul'jin's Guillotine Technique are the best trinkets in the current season. Voracious Heart is an on-use that grants a big chunk of Agility, so ideally it should be lined it up with Shadow Blades. Zul'jin's Guillotine Technique hits your target for 1% to 2% of their current missing health, so you'll want to pop it at the start of the fight and as soon as it comes off CD to use as an execute. Behind them, Keeper's Seething Core and Gebbo's Bottomless Bag from the raid, plus Tattered Amani War Banner and Freightrunner's Flask from dungeons, are all solid second best picks.

Zul'jin's Guillotine Technique is definitively a single-target trinket. It is still a matter of debate whether you want the extra priority and boss damage that comes with it, or whether you want to swap it for Gebbo's Bottomless Bag or Keeper's Seething Core in Mythic+ or cleavy fights. It's up to you to decide what your group needs more. If you just want to pad meters, the AoE options are likely to eke out a bit more damage overall.

Crafted Gear and Embellishments

Your best craft is a Farstrider's Mercy with the Hunter's Ritual Stone. Weapon crafts are the most efficient possible use of an early Spark. The second one should be a pair of Silvermoon Agent's Deflectors carrying Arcanoweave Lining, then use any further crafts to replace your lowest item level piece. Avoid crafting your head, legs or belt, since those slots have strong special-effect items and extra-upgradeable drops from the last two raid bosses.

Your two embellishments are Hunter's Ritual Stone on the dagger and Arcanoweave Lining on your crafted piece of choice.

Enchants and Gems

SlotEnchantment
Both WeaponsRite of the Hash'ey
HelmEmpowered Rune of Avoidance
ChestMark of the Worldsoul
ShouldersAmirdrassil's Grace
LegsForest Hunter's Armor Kit
BootsLynx's Dexterity
RingsEyes of the Eagle

Rite of the Hash'ey is your best in slot enchant. Smack it on your main and off hand and that's that. For gems, run Indecipherable Eversong Diamond in your Diamond slot. In the remaining sockets, Quick Amethyst and Masterful Peridot are both popular, and which one comes out ahead depends on how close you are to your Haste target. As usual, you wanna sim your character before you decide which one to settle on.

Consumables

TypeBest in Slot
FlaskFlask of the Magisters
Combat PotionLight's Potential
Health PotionConcentrated Silvermoon Health Potion
Weapon BuffThalassian Phoenix Oil
Augment RuneVoid-Touched Augment Rune
FoodSilvermoon Parade

Flask of the Magisters is the best, with Flask of the Shattered Sun as a close second. If you're still short your Haste cap, Fleeting Flask of the Blood Knights is a good stopgap. Light's Potential is the default combat potion, and Potion of Recklessness can be good if you're a gambling man. Thalassian Phoenix Oil goes on both daggers, and for food you want a feast like Silvermoon Parade for the raw Agility, with Royal Roast as the personal option. Make sure to wait until someone drops a feast in Mythic+ before eating your personal food, 90% of the time they'll see you haven't eaten and pop one down.

Professions and Races

Professions barely matter in Midnight, so pick whatever you like. Leatherworking lets you craft your own armour and gets you your crafted bracers, Alchemy covers your consumables, and Enchanting saves you buying enchants off the Auction House. None of these is a performance decision. If you are out and about with your main character between Mythics, Raids or PvP queue pops, you can get Herbalism and Mining to pad the bank. Actually turning a profit with your professions requires a bit more dedication. If you're into playing the craftsman, you'll want to check out our Professions & Crafting guides to properly build up your little cottage economy.

Min-maxing races is mostly a thing of the past, but if you're really keen on squeezing every last bit of damage out of your Sub Rogue, Tauren, Troll, Human and Dwarf have the best racials for Mythic+, while Orc and Night Elf are by far the most popular races on the PvP ladder.

Common Mistakes

The three things that most often hold Subtlety players back:

  • Pressing Shadow Dance without Secret Technique ready, which turns your daggers into noodles and craters your DPS
  • Pressing Shadow Dance during a global cooldown, wasting precious time inside a window that is only a few seconds long
  • Pressing a no-brain finisher right before Secret Technique comes off CD, enjoy losing a 30% DPS bump

Is Subtlety Worth Playing Right Now?

Do you like big numbers flashing on your screen? Do you like erasing people in one burst window? Do you like dispensing copious amounts of Black Powder? Then the answer is a resounding YES. Subtlety is nowhere near a consistent pick, and it isn't much to speak of in terms of cleave or slow, long fights. It is honest as can be and does one thing well: burst damage. It exists to cap out meters the second a fight starts and erase ill-prepared squishy cloth wearers. It tells you what it is up front, has reliable timers, a rotation that has stayed so consistent you could probably reach back in time and pluck a Legion Sub player and pop them into current-day WoW, and they'll know what to do right away, and a very strong position in any kind of content. Patch 12.1.5's Shadow damage rework is meant to fix how a lot of its weird interactions, so there's a good chance it ends up stronger after the patch than before it. That is, until Blizzard decides its time to test out its latest bit of gruesome game design by randomly swapping something or injecting some new interaction that gunks everything up for the 20th time. Who's to say?

Either way, that's all you need to play Sub Rogue today. If you'd like an easier go at it, without having to farm all that gear or grind your way through the hellish first ~2k Mythic rating where you just kinda run laps or pick herbs for 40+ minutes between keys because no one wants to invite you if you're undergeared nor join your low key because it's midway through the season and all the grinders are already at top rank so you get stuck with peole running their alts or new players so it becomes even more messy, then why not give our WoW Mythic+ or WoW Arena Boost services a try? We can do it all, be it raising you to a liveable Mythic rating or getting you through the initial 1800 Arena Rating grind, so that you can enjoy your Sub Rogue where the gameplay is actually good and does not involve wasting half your play time idling in Silvermoon (or Oribos if you have absolutely elite taste).

Best of all, we're running a 15% promotional discount offer on all of our services! All you need to do is pop the code BLOG15 into your checkout page to apply the discount to all items in your cart, be they for WoW, OSRS, League of Legends, or any other game on our website.

Should you need a hand getting your service set up, or have any questions you'd like answered, you can reach out to our 24/7 Customer Support Team through that little button in the bottom right hand corner of the page. They're available around the clock no matter where you are, so feel free to shoot them a message if there's anything you'd like to chat about. Stay tuned, because this guide's going to be getting updated with every new content release.

 

Our reviews

in 14 years of experience